The muzzling of Dr M - By Commander (Rtd) S THAYAPARAN Royal Malaysian Navy
Monday, July 10, 2017
Malaysiakini : “The one pervading evil of democracy is the tyranny of the
majority, or rather of that party, not always the majority, that
succeeds, by force or fraud, in carrying elections.”
- John Emerich Edward Dalberg-Acton
COMMENT | So now we have proof
that Umno members “cover” for their president. We have proof that the
corruption of Umno presidents are covered up by Umno members. We have
proof that Umno members will overlook any kind of malfeasances to keep
their leader in power.
We have this proof because, Umno vice-president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi,
who is now acting deputy president of the party, admitted as much when
he told former prime minister and de facto opposition leader Dr Mahathir
Mohamad (aka Our Great Leader) to shut up or recite Quranic verses to Allah, whichever comes
This is what Zahid said:
“He unveils the flaws of the present leaders, don’t forget we also used
to cover his flaws. Don’t let it be our turn to show his shame and
‘scabs’. There is so much that we can reveal.”
Let us unpack this statement. We can discern three important facts from it.
1) Zahid does not dispute that the current Umno leader and Prime
Minister Najib Abdul Razak has “flaws” and in this case, the only flaws
that the current de facto opposition leader Mahathir is unveiling are
the numerous corruption scandals that are plaguing this regime. You
would note that the Umno acting deputy president is not disputing those
flaws, indeed he acknowledges them as human “weakness” that every Umno
politician (leader) has.
2) He acknowledges that Umno members “cover” the flaws of their
leaders. So, as an Umno member, he is admitting that over the years Umno
has engaged in acts to cover the possibly criminal or unconstitutional
acts of their leaders to safeguard the position of Umno and the position
of the president of Umno and the office of prime minster of this
3) That by claiming “there is so much we can reveal”, Zahid is
admitting that Umno members have evidence of wrongdoing and have
purposely concealed these alleged criminal acts from the state security
apparatus, the judiciary, the press but more importantly, the public.
So, let me be clear. What Zahid’s statements reveal is that (1) Umno
members know that their leaders are corrupt (flaws); (2) that Umno
members cover for their leaders; and (3) Umno members have evidence of
the wrongdoings of their leaders.
How do Umno members cover for their leaders? Now, I am just
spitballing here, but they would have to ensure that their leaders are
insulated from the banalities of accountability. This would mean that
independent institutions that are meant to investigate and prosecute the
“flaws” of politicians would have to be accountable to members of Umno,
whose primary goal is to cover for their leaders. This would mean that the security apparatus, the judiciary and the
press would have to answer to Umno because these would be the
institutions that the Umno leader and prime minster would need
In other words, Umno members, like Zahid and every other Umno member
who are covering for their dear leader, are collaborators and/or
accomplices to the crimes committed by their president. Now I am not
making an accusation, I am merely clarifying what the Umno deputy
president said. So, when Umno members defend the indefensible, when they claim that
their leaders have done no wrong, when every state apparatus clears Umno
leaders of wrongdoing, what we are left with is the knowledge,
articulated by the Umno deputy president, that all this was done because
Umno members cover for their leaders.
So, this means that the so-called Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI)
on the foreign exchange market (forex) issue of the past is merely an
attempt by Umno members to “reveal” the wrongdoings of Mahathir? This
would also mean that this RCI is indeed politically motivated in defence
of the current Umno president and Malaysian prime minster because the
Zahid publicly threatened to “reveal” the “shame” and “scabs” of the
former prime minister.
And why was Salleh shocked?
So, let take this issue of the “appointments as additional judges to
the Federal Court”, which has received a fair amount of justified
criticism from members of the Bar and former judges. Former chief
justice (CJ) Abdul Hamid Mohamad had warned that “an extension of a CJ's
tenure beyond the 66 years and six months may compromise the
independence of the judiciary”.
In other words, what the Najib regime is doing may affect the
independence of the judiciary. This brings us to Communications and
Multimedia Minister Salleh Said Keruak’s shocking revelation that Mahathir, in his interview with The Guardian implied that jailed political prisoner Anwar Ibrahim “was fixed up by a corrupt judiciary and the judges were dishonest.”
Here is the problem. If Umno members cover for their leaders and the
only way they can do this is if they control the apparatus of the state,
then why is it shocking that a former prime minister implies that the
state, through the judiciary covered, up a political problem for an Umno
president? If Umno members cover for their leaders, and the only way they can
cover for their leaders is by controlling the apparatus of the state and
concealing evidence (as articulated by Zahid), then why is it a
surprise to the communications and multimedia minster that the former
prime minister implies a conspiracy by the state (during his tenure) to
imprison a political opponent?
If by stacking the judiciary in favour of Umno politicians means that
it would be easier to “cover” the flaws of Umno presidents, then why
should we be surprised by the fears and warnings that this would lead to
an unnatural relationship between the executive and the judiciary as
articulated by former CJ Abdul Hamid?
With this in mind, how can we not believe that this move by the
Registrar of Societies (ROS) to compel the DAP to hold a further round
of its central executive committee (CEC) elections is anything but a
political gambit by the Umno state to neutralise a political opponent of
a compromised Umno president before the upcoming general election?
Concerning this crippling of the DAP, this quote from Lim Kit Siang’s blog needs to be addressed. “In fact, it has led even independent observers to swallow hook, line
and sinker to believe in these fake news and false information. For
instance, one independent commentator described the whole ROS fiasco as
‘a ticking time bomb of DAP’s own design’ that should have been
addressed a long time ago in a transparent manner. How is the ROS fiasco
‘DAP’s own design’?”
Which is the more plausible proposition?
1) That I have swallowed hook, line and sinker the fake news and false information of this regime and its propagandists. Or
2) That I was sincerely questioning the strategies (as it were) of an
opposition political party that is in the crosshairs of this regime,
the state apparatus that they control and the propagandists who serve
them. I will leave rational readers to decide which they think is more plausible.
Ultimately, muzzling Mahathir says more of the collective guilt and
complicity of Umno members, rather than the agenda of the former prime
minister turned de facto opposition leader.